substitute for butter in oatmeal cookies

Oatmeal cookies are a beloved treat, known for their chewy texture and delightful flavors. While butter plays a crucial role in these cookies, there are various reasons why you might consider substitutes. Whether you’re looking to cater to dietary preferences, health goals, or allergy concerns, this article explores the purpose of butter in oatmeal cookies, reasons to opt for alternatives, and a range of substitutes that can transform your cookie baking experience.

Purpose of Butter in Oatmeal Cookies:

  • Flavor Enhancer: Butter contributes a rich and buttery flavor that complements the oats and other ingredients.
  • Texture: It helps create a tender and moist texture in the cookies.
  • Browning: Butter aids in achieving a golden-brown color on the edges of the cookies.
  • Binding Agent: It helps hold the cookie dough together and provides structure.
  • Moisture Retention: Butter helps retain moisture, keeping the cookies soft and chewy.

Why Replace Butter in Oatmeal Cookies:

  • Dairy-Free Preferences: Individuals with dairy-free diets can enjoy oatmeal cookies without using butter.
  • Healthier Options: Some substitutes offer healthier fat profiles and nutritional benefits.
  • Reducing Saturated Fat: Using alternatives can help lower the saturated fat content in the cookies.
  • Varied Flavors: Exploring substitutes can introduce new and exciting flavor dimensions to the cookies.
  • Allergies: Those with dairy allergies or lactose intolerance can safely enjoy oatmeal cookies.

Substitute: Coconut Oil

Details: Coconut oil adds a subtle tropical aroma and a chewy texture to oatmeal cookies.

Nutrient Amount per 1/4 cup
Calories 480
Total Fats 56g
Carbohydrates 0g
Proteins 0g

How to Make: Melt and use an equal amount of coconut oil in place of butter for your oatmeal cookie dough.

Substitute: Avocado

Details: Mashed avocado adds a creamy texture and healthy fats to oatmeal cookies.

Nutrient Amount per 1/4 cup
Calories 80
Total Fats 7g
Carbohydrates 4g
Proteins 1g

How to Make: Mash ripe avocado and use it as a replacement for butter in your oatmeal cookie recipe.

Substitute: Greek Yogurt

Details: Greek yogurt adds tanginess, moisture, and protein to oatmeal cookies.

Nutrient Amount per 1/4 cup
Calories 35
Total Fats 0g
Carbohydrates 6g
Proteins 6g

How to Make: Replace butter with an equal amount of Greek yogurt to enhance the texture and nutritional profile of your cookies.

Substitute: Nut Butter

Details: Nut butter imparts a nutty flavor and hearty consistency to oatmeal cookies.

Nutrient Amount per 1/4 cup
Calories 280-340
Total Fats 24-32g
Carbohydrates 8-12g
Proteins 8-12g

How to Make: Substitute an equal amount of your preferred nut butter for butter in your oatmeal cookie recipe.

Substitute: Applesauce

Details: Unsweetened applesauce adds natural sweetness and moisture to oatmeal cookies.

Nutrient Amount per 1/4 cup
Calories 25
Total Fats 0g
Carbohydrates 7g
Proteins 0g

How to Make: Use an equal amount of unsweetened applesauce in place of butter to keep your cookies moist and tender.

Nutritional Facts Summary Table:

Substitute Calories Total Fats Carbohydrates Proteins Source Works Best In
Coconut Oil 480 56g 0g 0g Coconut Chewy and tropical-flavored cookies
Avocado 80 7g 4g 1g Avocado Health-conscious and creamy-textured cookies
Greek Yogurt 35 0g 6g 6g Yogurt Moist and protein-rich cookies
Nut Butter 280-340 24-32g 8-12g 8-12g Nuts or Seeds Nutty and hearty cookies
Applesauce 25 0g 7g 0g Apples Naturally sweet and moist cookies


Q: Will using coconut oil change the flavor of my oatmeal cookies?
A: Yes, coconut oil adds a subtle tropical aroma that can enhance the flavor profile of your cookies.

Q: Can I taste the avocado in the cookies?
A: No, the avocado flavor is typically masked by the other ingredients, leaving behind its creamy texture.

Q: Is Greek yogurt a suitable substitute for dairy-free cookies?
A: Greek yogurt is not dairy-free, but you can opt for dairy-free yogurt alternatives.

Q: Can I use nut butter in gluten-free oatmeal cookies?
A: Yes, nut butter can be used in gluten-free recipes to add flavor and texture.


Exploring substitutes for butter in oatmeal cookies opens up a world of flavor possibilities, accommodating dietary needs and health considerations. Whether you choose the tropical notes of coconut oil, the creaminess of avocado, the tanginess of Greek yogurt, the nutty richness of nut butter, or the natural sweetness of applesauce, each alternative imparts a unique twist to your cookies. Embrace the versatility of these substitutes and delight in baking oatmeal cookies that suit your individual tastes and preferences.

Yuki Tanaka

Written by Yuki Tanaka

I'm from Utashinai and I love tasty food and nice words. I also write blogs, take pictures of food, and create recipes. Cooking and baking are my favorite things to do!

substitute for chocolate chips in brownies

substitute for butter in a recipe